Halloween “Would You Rather” Questions for the Classroom (50+ Fun Ideas)

Halloween “Would You Rather” is an easy and fun classroom game. You can play it with the whole class, in pairs, or in small groups. Just read a question and let students pick their answer. It’s perfect for brain breaks, warm-ups, parties, or even review games if you mix in some subject questions. No prep needed. Just print or display the questions and start playing!

Halloween Would You Rather Questions

1. Would you rather get only chocolate or only gummy candy on Halloween?
2. Would you rather have a giant lollipop or a giant chocolate bar?
3. Would you rather eat candy corn or caramel apples for a week?
4. Would you rather trade all your candy for money or keep it?
5. Would you rather eat a mystery Halloween treat or your least favorite candy?
6. Would you rather have unlimited Halloween candy but no chocolate, or unlimited chocolate but no candy?
7. Would you rather dress up as a vampire or a zombie?
8. Would you rather wear a funny costume or a scary one?
9. Would you rather have a homemade costume or a store-bought one?
10. Would you rather be a superhero on Halloween or a monster?
11. Would you rather have your costume come to life or your decorations?
12. Would you rather dress up the same as your teacher or your best friend?
13. Would you rather wear a costume that’s too big or too small?
14. Would you rather spend a night in a haunted house or in a graveyard?
15. Would you rather explore a dark forest or a creepy abandoned mansion?
16. Would you rather carve pumpkins in a graveyard or in a corn maze?
17. Would you rather trick-or-treat in a spooky neighborhood or a huge city?
18. Would you rather get lost in a haunted maze or stuck in a foggy forest?
19. Would you rather walk through a haunted house alone or with a jumpy friend?
20. Would you rather have a pet bat or a pet black cat?
21. Would you rather meet a friendly ghost or a friendly witch?
22. Would you rather have a skeleton as a best friend or a vampire as a neighbor?
23. Would you rather fight off a pack of werewolves or a group of zombies?
24. Would you rather turn into a ghost at night or a werewolf?
25. Would you rather have spiders crawl all over you or bats fly around you?
26. Would you rather share a house with a mummy or a mad scientist?
27. Would you rather go trick-or-treating with your class or your family?
28. Would you rather hand out candy or collect it?
29. Would you rather go to a Halloween parade or a Halloween movie night?
30. Would you rather win “Funniest Costume” or “Scariest Costume”?
31. Would you rather tell a spooky story or act one out?
32. Would you rather make your own haunted house or visit one?
33. Would you rather have pumpkin pie toothpaste or candy corn soup?
34. Would you rather have to wear a pumpkin on your head all day or carry a broom everywhere?
35. Would you rather get chased by 100 tiny skeletons or 1 giant ghost?
36. Would you rather sneeze cobwebs or hiccup candy corn?
37. Would you rather your teacher dress up like a clown or a witch for a day?
38. Would you rather your classroom be filled with balloons or fake spiders?
39. Would you rather have glowing red eyes or sharp vampire teeth for a day?
40. Would you rather have to howl at the moon or float through walls?
41. Would you rather live in a pumpkin house or a haunted castle?
42. Would you rather your school be haunted or your home?
43. Would you rather sleep in a coffin or on a pile of candy?
44. Would you rather turn your teacher into a frog or a ghost?
45. Would you rather trick-or-treat in the rain or in the snow?
46. Would you rather your Halloween bag rip open halfway through or get no candy at all?
47. Would you rather eat only orange food or only black food on Halloween?
48. Would you rather ride on a witch’s broom or fly with bats?
49. Would you rather wear the same costume every year or a brand-new one each time?
50. Would you rather your costume glow in the dark or make spooky noises?
51. Would you rather be invisible on Halloween night or be able to fly?
52. Would you rather have fake blood on your costume or fake cobwebs in your hair?
53. Would you rather make a potion that works for one day or see a ghost for real?
54. Would you rather spend Halloween at a spooky carnival or a giant haunted house?

Teacher Tips

• You can play as a quick game or stretch it out into a full Halloween lesson.
• Let students explain their answers for extra speaking practice.
• Add review questions after each “Would You Rather” to turn it into a learning game.